EmploymentCrossing
log in 

JOB SEEKERS, Try it Now 

EMPLOYERS, Post Jobs 
Search Resumes
 

What Where


Search in Job Title Only

upload your resume

Select Country:


+ Browse Jobs    + Advanced Search    + Search Tips
Jobs >> Articles >> Employment Career Feature >> ''I Didn't Marry This Job, I'm Just Dating It'': The Value of Discretionary Effort
  • Employment Career Feature
''I Didn't Marry This Job, I'm Just Dating It'': The Value of Discretionary Effort

by Bill Catlette and Richard Hadden     
My 33-year-old son recently remarked, ''People no longer marry their jobs — they just date them.'' Having worked for virtually every casual-themed restaurant chain in America, he speaks from experience. When his comment finished sinking in, I realized two things: 1) he's right, and 2) that statement is pretty profound.

''I Didn't Marry This Job, I'm Just Dating It'': The Value of Discretionary Effort
''I Didn't Marry This Job, I'm Just Dating It'': The Value of Discretionary Effort
+ Enlarge
People no longer marry their jobs — they just date them.
Not long ago, Economist.com ran a piece summarizing a European Union survey of the average job tenure of workers in each of 17 countries throughout Europe and North America. The average job span ranged from four years in the US to 13 years in Greece. Even with the less-than-stellar odds that come with wedding vows, four years is still probably closer to dating territory than marriage, right? Score one for the kid.

When one considers the amount of fooling around that occurs early on in a relationship (work or personal), and the absolute dysfunction that exists in the breakup stage, there isn’t a lot of productive time in the middle. So, in the workplace, managers are faced with about a three-year window that is largely devoid of loyalty, commitment, and — but for occasional outbreaks — passion. We’re just dating!

It should be no surprise, then, that in one ''engagement'' study after another (e.g., Towers Perrin, Gallup), employees are shown to be operating with the ole effort meter at something well shy of ''balls to the wall.'' More specifically, most people are, by their own admission, contributing only 60 to 70 percent of their maximum effort to their job. But here’s where it gets interesting: Most folks allow that, under the right circumstances, they could and would contribute more effort…a lot more. In other words, inside each of us there is a wellspring of effort — discretionary effort (we sometimes call it ''Oomph'') — just waiting to get out. Sadly, however, too much of it goes home at day’s end, unspent.

There are many ways managers can tap into this discretionary effort, which is one of the greatest natural (and free) sources of competitive advantage. On the premise that the default position for Oomph for most people is ''on,'' one of the smartest things we manager-types can do is to avoid turning the spigot off. What follows are some thoughts on how to keep things flowing.

Work Needs to Matter

When people begin to entertain the question, ''What’s the point?'' their Oomph pumps start shutting down. That happens when they begin to question whether their jobs have any real value to anyone — their managers, the organization, or most of all, customers.

In spite of this danger, the following scenario happens with alarming regularity. A manager assigns people to a project, creating the impression that the resultant work will be applied to some important organizational need. Initially, the workers exert significant discretionary effort, proudly presenting the finished product to the manager who requested it. When the product is then relegated to the shelf, never to see the light of day, the worker learns that it’s not in his or her best interest to put too much into such requests. The Oomph turns off.

Standards Are Lax

In some organizations, it doesn’t seem to matter if the work is done well, only that it gets done. People soon adopt the stance that, ''If my manager doesn’t care whether or not I knock myself out, I certainly don’t.''

''I Didn't Marry This Job, I'm Just Dating It'': The Value of Discretionary Effort
Bill Catlette and Richard Hadden are the authors of the newly released Contented Cows MOOve Faster.
Hardworking people want to work in the company of equally competent, committed, and honest individuals. They will pull someone else’s weight for a while, especially if there’s a good reason, one they understand. But they’re loath to bear others’ yokes for the duration of a journey. Similarly, when managers turn a blind eye to dishonest, unethical, or unprofessional behavior, there are serious downside implications for discretionary effort.It sends signals you don’t want to send, and slows things down by diluting trust.

One of the surest, fastest ways to tank ''Oomph'' is by lowering your hiring and performance standards.

Jeromy Williams, owner-operator of a Jacksonville, Florida, Chick-fil-A — a company widely known and appreciated for utilizing the discretionary effort of its employees — says, ''Everybody goes through three interviews. We don’t just hire people off the street. We’ll all work twice as hard for as long as we have to until we find the right one.''

With a little luck and some hard work, we should be surrounded by people who are eager to do good work, and proud of it when they do. Why is it then that so many of these bright, well-intentioned employees end up losing their Oomph? Here are five reasons why:

1. Because managers have the audacity to tell people that they are ''empowered'' to do their work, yet they then place ridiculous limits on their ability to fix problems and satisfy customers. If your people can’t unilaterally commit an amount of the company’s funds equivalent to a month of their salary or wages to satisfy a customer, stop using the term ''empowered.''

2. Because there’s a ''supervisor'' for every six or seven worker bees. Do your people really need that much supervision? Are they that incompetent?

3. Because managers bail their people out constantly, or worse, take over when they see them struggling. ''Oh, forget it. I’ll just do it myself.'' Truth be told, everyone needs the benefit of some fire drill opportunities. As Mark Twain once put it, ''A man who carries a cat home by the tail learns ten times as much as one who only watches.''

4. Because too often, managers burden folks deemed bright, experienced, and well-intentioned when they’re hired with a ''To-Don’t'' list of policies and procedures that cause them to lose any appetite for using their brains. Or, because managers insist on personally reviewing and approving any information, recommendations, or reports that are destined for points north of them in the food chain.

5. Because entirely too often, managers keep paying those who consistently require the kind of supervisory oversight spelled out in items 1 through 4 above.

It’s been said that, in the final analysis, you really can’t motivate people. While that’s an argument best left for another day, one thing is for sure: Work gets done a lot better and a lot faster if we don’t de-motivate our people in the first place. Good luck and Godspeed.

About the Authors

Bill Catlette and Richard Hadden are the authors of the newly released Contented Cows MOOve Faster. The two founded Contented Cow Partners, LLC to help business and organization leaders produce better results through a focused, fired-up, and capably led workforce. For more information, visit www.ContentedCows.com.

Popular tags:

 Mark Twain  employers  North America  no surprise  policies and procedures
Rate this article:

       current rating: 8
Printable Version  printable version PDF Version  PDF version Email to a Friend  email to a friend Comment  add comments

Comments

article ID: 230213     http://www.employmentcrossing.com/article/230213/I-Didn-t-Marry-This-Job-I-m-Just-Dating-It-The-Value-of-Discretionary-Effort/

article title: ''I Didn't Marry This Job, I'm Just Dating It'': The Value of Discretionary Effort
Comment not found for this article.
add comments add comments

Related articles


Facebook comments:


Find Jobs in Every Industry and Location that No One Else Knows About

Other job sites only show jobs employers pay to post.

We show jobs from every employer career page, job board and news source we can find.
Tell us where to send your access instructions:

Your Email:     
new jobs this week
on EmploymentCrossing
920,368
jobs added today
on EmploymentCrossing
248,603
job type count
on EmploymentCrossing
Healthcare Jobs
364,203

Information Technology Jobs
303,796

Managerial Jobs
303,390

Recruiting Jobs
235,825

Blue-collar Jobs
233,012

Retail Jobs
213,695

Sales Jobs
208,568
top 5 job searches
Get your risk FREE trial
jobs near you
International jobs
Work at home jobs
UK jobs
Canada jobs
New search feature using US map. click here

Looking for a new job in your city? click here
Sign Up now
*Email:


VeriSign Secure Site  

Only EmploymentCrossing consolidates every job it can find in the domain and puts all of the job listings it locates in one place.

  • We have more jobs than any other job board.
  • We list jobs you will not find elsewhere that are hidden in small regional publications and employer websites.
  • We collect jobs from more than 3,574,992 websites and post them on our site.
  • Employers can post jobs for free at EmploymentCrossing.
  • We are private, and therefore far fewer people are applying for the jobs on our site than are applying for those on public job boards.

    today's featured job
    Director of Human Resources
    United States-CA-San Francisco

    We Are Looking To Hire A Director Of Human Resources To Manage The Activities Of All Three Us Locations, Reporting Into The Vp Of Global Hr. The.....

    Click to Apply for - EmploymentCrossing.com
    post your resume
    • Make your resume viewable to thousands of employers.
    • Employers can look you up in our database.
    • Get job alerts based on your resume.
    upload your resume

    Your privacy is guaranteed. We will never give out, lease, or sell your personal information.


    Employment Research Institute

    Privacy Policy by TRUSTe  VeriSign Secure Site
    EmploymentCrossing - #1 Job Aggregation and Private Job-Opening Research Service — The Most Quality Jobs Anywhere
    EmploymentCrossing is the first job consolidation service in the employment industry to seek to include every job that exists and not charge employers to post jobs on its site. EmploymentCrossing uses sophisticated technology and manual work to comb employer websites and other job boards for jobs and bring them all to its site.

    Copyright © 2012 EmploymentCrossing - All rights reserved.